Wake County student speaks before school board after she says she was falsely accused of using AI to cheat
And our first student speaker
Good evening and welcome to the podium
Uh hello
My name is Eleanor Kaina and I'm a current student
at Green Hope High School
I was recently accused of using AI on an assignment
which I did not
This experience made me realize the growing prevalence of the
issue
Students being accused of using AI on their work when
they didn't
Needs to be treated as a real concern
I understand that this is uncharted territory
There are absolutely students who are using AI to cheat
on their assignments and teachers are doing their best to
navigate the circumstances
But false accusations along with being incredibly unfair cause a
great deal of stress for students
Students in this situation don't have an easy way of
responding
As such I think protections need to be put in
place for students to prevent these false accusations
Teachers should not be able to accuse students of using
AI without a conversation first and grades should not be
put in based on assumptions like occurred in my particular
experience
One major cause of these false accusations is the usage
of AI detectors
These AI detectors have been proven to give both false
positives and false negatives
They are agreed on by experts to not be suited
to be used as sole evidence against students
Rules need to be put in place to protect students
from accusations backed up by these technologies
I also think it would be worthwhile to consider the
privacy concerns associated with these AI detectors
Random detectors found online by teachers do not ensure that
the data or writing input will not be stored or
used to train AI models
Students should not have to be having their work submitted
into the software without permission
Ultimately this is a complicated situation and there isn't one
clear solution
However it's important to start making policy and above all
else consulting students in the process
Students are the ones directly affected by the situation and
can offer important insight on how their work should be
judged
Uh thank you for the time
Thank you and I'm gonna see if Doctor Robinson or
Doctor Hill is actually going to speak with you regarding
your concern
So Doctor Hill will join you
On one side um great thank you sorry for that
confusion