Trump debate claim is 2024 'Lie of the Year'

In choosing the 2024 Lie of the Year, the claims by JD Vance and Donald Trump about Haitians eating pets stood out. It was an absurd statement that Trump raised unprompted on the debate stage.
Posted 12/18/2024, 11:22:57 PM Updated 12/19/2024, 1:59:33 AM

75 PARTIAL ACCESS AT THIS POINT

AND 187 ARE STILL COMPLETELY

CLOSE. 2024 WAS AN ELECTION

YEAR, OF COURSE, WHICH MEANS

THAT FACT CHECKERS IDENTIFIED

HUNDREDS OF MISLEADING CLAIMS

ABOUT THE CANDIDATES, THE

POLITICAL PARTIES AND THE TOP

ISSUES. AND AT THE END OF EVERY

YEAR, OUR PARTNERS AT

POLITIFACT PICK ONE FALSE CLAIM

THAT HAD THE LARGEST IMPACT

THAT WAS ABOVE THE REST.

>> PAUL SPAY HAS MORE NOW ON

POLITIFACT LIE OF THE YEAR.

>> FOR YEARS NOW, POLITIFACT

HAS BEEN AWARDING THE LIE OF

THE YEAR TO A QUOTE OR A

COMMENT THAT STOOD OUT AND

GENERATE THE MOST BUZZ OVER A

CALENDAR YEAR. AND YOU CAN SEE

SOME OF THE PAST WINNERS HERE

LAST YEAR WHEN TO RFK JUNIOR'S

CLAIMS ABOUT VACCINES YEAR

BEFORE VLADIMIR PUTIN'S FALSE

CLAIMS ABOUT UKRAINE. RESIDENTS

ON BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE HAVE

WON THIS AWARD. AND THIS YEAR

IT'S GOING TO A PRESIDENT ONCE

AGAIN THIS TIME FOR SPREADING

FALSEHOOD ABOUT IMMIGRANTS AND

OHIO.

>> SINCE SPRINGFIELD, THEY'RE

EATING THE DOGS. THE PEOPLE

THAT CAME IN THERE EATING THE

EATING THE PETS OF THE PEOPLE

THAT LIVE THERE.

>> REMEMBER THAT MOMENT FROM

THIS YEAR'S PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE

THAT CLAIM THAT HAITIAN

IMMIGRANTS WERE EATING CATS

AND DOGS DOMINATED HEADLINES

FOR WEEKS DESPITE THE FACT THAT

SPRINGFIELD TOWN OFFICIALS

LOOKED INTO THIS ROOM AND FOUND

NO VERIFIED REPORTS. GENERATED

BACKLASH NOT ONLY AGAINST THE

TOWN'S HAITIAN COMMUNITY, BUT

AGAINST THE WHOLE TOWN. THERE

ARE MORE THAN 30 THREATS TO

TOWN OFFICIALS, HOSPITAL.

EVEN THE SCHOOL'S OHIO'S

GOVERNOR HAD TO DISPATCH STATE

TROOPERS JUST TO ENSURE SCHOOL

SAFETY. IN FACT, ONE OF THE

WOMEN WHO FIRST SPREAD THIS

RUMOR ON FACEBOOK, PEOPLE FOUND

HER AND SHE RETRACTED HER

STATEMENT AND SAID SHE HAD NO

FIRSTHAND KNOWLEDGE OF LOCAL

IMMIGRANT STEALING PETS, LET

ALONE EATING THEM. SHE DIDN'T

REALIZE THAT HER CLAIMS WOULD

GO AS FAR AS THEY DID. STILL,

OHIO SENATOR JD VANCE, TRUMP

RUNNING MATE. HE DEFENDED

SPREADING MISINFORMATION.

HE TOLD CNN IF I HAVE TO CREATE

STORIES SO THE MEDIA PAYS

ATTENTION TO THE SUFFERING OF

AMERICANS. AND THAT'S WHAT I'M

GOING TO DO. CLEARLY, THIS WAS

A BASELESS RUMOR WEAPONIZED

BY POLITICAL CAMPAIGN AND

SPREAD FAR AND WIDE DURING A

TELEVISED PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE.

THAT'S WHY THIS CLAIM ABOUT

IMMIGRANTS EATING DOGS AND

CATS. IT'S OUR LIE OF THE YEAR.